High: 31° / Low: 18° — Dude Weather Subscribe to Secrets Minneapolis / St. Paul

MNSpeak: Talk

Citizen Journalism

Metroblogging points us to a forthcoming UBS forum about online journalism, featuring MnSpeak's own Chuck Olsen. And good timing as well, as Chuck's video interview with several ill-informed churchgoers in Tennessee is blowing up on the Internet.

133 Reader Comments

mnblrmkr  url02:02am
Feb 19

No offense, but I'll take Chuck and things like TheUptake seriously when there's a serious effort to make their content accessible. to people like myself.

chuck02:29am
Feb 19

mnblrmkr: Your blanket dismissal of my hard work and online video is frustrating as usual, but I understand it must be more frustrating being left out. Care to help us apply for grants? Not trying to make excuses, but even organizations that actually HAVE the resources to caption online video aren't often doing it.

I just did a little research to see if there are any new tools out there for captioning. Good news, there is: Overstream. Haven't tried it yet, but this is definitely something we can get UpTake volunteers to do for our videos. If we have the people, the passion, and the tools, we can do anything the big boys can (maybe even better).

chuck02:46am
Feb 19

By the way, the Rocketboom version of that Tennessee church ladies video is edited. The full-on original is here: "We Need God in Our Governments"

Cheryl Colan (not verified)02:48am
Feb 19

I completely agree that there needs to be some form of captioning for online video to make it accessible to the hearing-impaired. However, I'd like to remind everyone that there is NO industry standard for such a thing, and creating captions currently requires a video producer to double, triple, or even quadruple the time spent preparing video for Internet distribution. In time-sensitive material, like election-related video produced by The Uptake, captioning with currently available technology would be prohibitive to getting any message out at all. That's not an excuse. But it IS a reality.

jderusha06:09am
Feb 19

Redlasso's videoplayer appears to search broadcast's captioning, which is cool. But, no offense, David-- but it's unfair to hijack the thread into a captioning discussion. That's not even close to what the post was about.

Comments sponsored by
kwatt06:28am
Feb 19

Did she call him Bahama?

The Rat (not verified)07:04am
Feb 19

Awright, these three women are somewhat ill informed. I read stuff here and elsewhere every day that makes me wince.

Shoving a camera in the face of some unsophisticated people in a small town who have an old-style religious faith and a southern drawl is just too damned easy.

justpbob  url07:06am
Feb 19

A couple of Jason's co-workers and I were discussing this very topic recently (blog journalism ethics, not captioning). I've got my ticket.

Post Event Get Together in St. Paul? -- Drinks at the Depot? A burger at Mickey's? Birdbath Martinis at the St. Paul Grill bar!

leigha07:34am
Feb 19

Shoving a camera in the face of some unsophisticated people in a small town who have an old-style religious faith and a southern drawl is just too damned easy.

It might be "easy," but I don't see how it's any less relevant. They clearly aren't the only ones who share those same uninformed, second-hand political views, and they're voters. That seems like awfully important information to me.

adam07:43am
Feb 19

I agree. I have lots of relatives in central Minnesota who feel basically the same way, or at least entertain equally astounding misconceptions.

justpbob  url07:56am
Feb 19

You a closet Huckabee supporter, Rat? I kinda like Mike myself.

Look, no one "shoved a camera" in the face of these women, they were happy to share their views with their visitor from Minneapolis. You can here much of the same, with slightly different accents, at any number of locations in the upper Midwest. Yes, even in "sophisticated, liberal Minneapolis."

I thought their views on Bush and Iraq, while not clearly spelled out, were the most interesting. Clearly, they -- like Bahama supporters -- want change.

I wonder if Keith Ellison has seen this yet....Maybe we should start a rumor that he is secretly a Baptist, and that was a Bible after all.

justpbob  url07:58am
Feb 19

you can hear, rather.

mazasapa07:59am
Feb 19

They clearly aren't the only ones who share those same uninformed, second-hand political views, and they're voters. That seems like awfully important information to me.

You could get laughably uninformed political nonsense in downtown chicago. Or minninapolis, for that matter.

justpbob  url08:14am
Feb 19

Maz is right.

Gasp -- these ARE the End Times!

mazasapa08:16am
Feb 19

Like for example, I'd love to ask some young swooning girl why shy supports Obama and see what she says.

I bet it would be no less moronic.

St Paul Girl (not verified)08:32am
Feb 19

I'm from Tennessee originally. And let's just say I'm NOT surprised such folks were found. They are in large quantities in the South, but especially in places like Lynchburg, TN. I've told friends and acquaintances here in MN I escaped a bullet by running as fast as possible from that state. Many many folks are like those ladies. Do not be surprised if the Republicans takes that state during the election again.

mazasapa08:39am
Feb 19

I've told friends and acquaintances here in MN I escaped a bullet by running as fast as possible from that state.

I can't believe they would try to stop you from leaving.

Mpls Simpleton (not verified)08:43am
Feb 19

Unless there is a gay marriage amendment most of those people don't take the time to vote anyhow. I didn't think they were that outrageous really. I am so inundated with morons on a daily basis that outrage over some statements supporting the most religious candidate made by some people in the south seems manufactured.

justpbob  url08:57am
Feb 19

It's a little more complicated that that, Simpleton. Long considered a voting bloc that support any Republican candidate, the Christian right has evolved (no pun intended) into a much more complex and diverse group(s). Some are rejecting politics all together. Others have embraced environmentalism and global climate change as an issue. In many states, self-described Christian conservatives have evenly split their vote between Huckabee, McCain and Romney.

This year, I wouldn't count on "traditional wisdom" too much to predict election results. We are all living in interesting times.

leigha09:04am
Feb 19

You could get laughably uninformed political nonsense in downtown chicago. Or minninapolis, for that matter.

Oh Maz, it's lovely to see you finally doing some self-reflection and ultimate recognition. It puts a tear in my eye. *sniff*

DouglasG  url09:16am
Feb 19

Leigha FTW!!!!

justpbob  url09:21am
Feb 19

Enough snipe 'n snark. Anyone else going, other than me and chuck?

JasonB09:24am
Feb 19

Chuck interviewed a wide range of people during his road trip. To see a few more examples of this, see these videos. The first one goes into a few more similar extremes, and the later one is a southern professor talking in depth about political tends in Alabama.

St. Louis: What Does America Need?

Alabama Politics 101

There are many misconceptions out there about politics, and many disturbing points of views. One of the biggest differences with the religious extremists is that one of their church leaders is intentionally feeding them false information regarding Obama. That should raise many questions in itself.

noodleman  url09:29am
Feb 19

Shoving a camera in the face of some unsophisticated people in a small town who have an old-style religious faith and a southern drawl is just too damned easy.

Here's the thing, Rat: It's one thing to be personally ignorant of current events. It's another thing entirely to be told lies by leaders (political, religious or otherwise). The former can be more easily corrected than the latter.

What's entirely assinine about these Obama = Muslim lies is that Barack attended an Indonesian school many years ahead of the current Wahabist movement. While Indonesia has had its share of Islam x Christian x Buddhist x Hindu violence over the years, the clashes have not, until this decade, carried any "jihad" connotation to them.

How many Americans are even aware that Bali, for example, is a Hindu enclave, the remnant of a large, regional Sanskrit empire that first arrived from India around 100 A.D.? Hindu colonization was then followed by the introduction of Buddhism into the archipelago around 500 A.D., the Nayang period that is also associated with Imperial China's great global explorations? Islam didn't reach Indonesia until at least the 14th century and did not become a significant political factor there until the 16th century.

P.S. It's a shame bin Laden's name isn't Boosh. What fun could we have with that!

mazasapa09:30am
Feb 19

Oh Maz, it's lovely to see you finally doing some self-reflection and ultimate recognition. It puts a tear in my eye. *sniff*

cept, I live in st. paul. Were did you say you live leigha?

josie09:34am
Feb 19

Wow, did MnSpeak have a cup of bitchy with their breakfast this morning? There's a whole lot of sniping happening for before 10am.

The Rat (not verified)09:35am
Feb 19

Didn't notice.

The Rat (not verified)09:36am
Feb 19

Didn't notice.

josie09:38am
Feb 19

Maybe I'm overly mellow since I'm not working today.

mazasapa09:42am
Feb 19

I watched the street interviews in St. Louis. Now you tell me why anything they said was any less stupid than what the religious people said.

"I'm voting for the black guy, cuz I don't like no wimins for prezident."

grote (not verified)09:47am
Feb 19

maz is a man who will fight for your honor
he'll be the hero that you're dreaming of

mazasapa09:48am
Feb 19

eh uh.

Mpls Simpleton (not verified)09:52am
Feb 19

Only 57% of eligible voters in Tennessee bothered to vote last Presidential Election. The number of electoral votes your state should get should be apportioned on the percent of eligible voters that actually vote.

Minnesota and Wisconsin lead the way with 77% and 76% respectively.

jderusha10:18am
Feb 19

Bob, I'm hoping to make it over. Just so I can hear what my boss has to say, and then follow his instructions. :-)

rew10:48am
Feb 19

"Enough snipe 'n snark. Anyone else going, other than me and chuck?"

I have a ticket, but I'm still about 50/50 on whether I can make it or not. Very much intending to.

justpbob  url10:53am
Feb 19

Always good to see you, Robin. Wished I had more time to talk last time at the 331, but I was just getting off a long day of work and travel and I was pretty fried.

ericam  url11:01am
Feb 19

I'm planning on being there. I want to see Chuck leg wrestle with Bob Collins. And, as I said in the MB comments, I'm looking forward to seeing someone new and different address the topic instead of the usual clutch-the-pearls, have-my-cake-and-eat-it-too local folks.

Somewhat related I just listened to a Commonwealth Club talk from 2006 by Randall Ballmer entitled "An Evangelical's Lament on Politicized Religion". Great background on how the "Christian Right" movement came to be.

mazasapa11:16am
Feb 19

Great background on how the "Christian Right" movement came to be.

Ballmer's a very confused fellow. His argument shouldn't be with the right, but with the left. It's the left that ridicules his beliefs and is the home of american atheists and agnostics, not the right. He may not agree with all of the right's policies and philosophies, but at least they allow him to disagree without ridicule.

Evangelicals weren't kidnapped by the right. The right offered them refuge from the haters.

Max Sparber  url11:19am
Feb 19

You just make stuff up to suit your political views, don't you?

jpavleck11:37am
Feb 19

Ooooo hey Chuck! I just might see you there, think I might be tapped to photog that event. I'm actually transitioning myself into a 501(c)3, taking photographs for non-profits and other such things that need quality photos, but have no money for them.

mnblrmkr  url11:41am
Feb 19

no offense, David-- but it's unfair to hijack the thread into a captioning discussion. That's not even close to what the post was about.

It never is, Jason. It never is. I didnt intend to hijack the thread (which it looks like I didnt), Max is free to delete my comment if he sees fit. But it was about citizen journalism, and I think I have legitimate concerns about a real failing, even more so, given the number of people giddily prognosticating the demise of print, or declaring that broadcast is dead. Im just trying to see where the upside for me in this is.

If this is going to be the new paradigm, its an issue that has to be discussed, along side the ethics issues that the UBS forum looks to discuss, especially since, by its very nature, citizen journalism is going to be done by individuals, or at best, small organizations working on tight budgets. How many people involved in this even think about the issue before its brought to their attention?

Cheryl, I dont think its entirely accurate to say that there are no standards. True, each of the main media players (Windows Media, Quicktime, Flash, and Real) handle them differently, but once you choose a platform for your operation, it should be fairly standardized.

Chuck, I dont mean to dismiss the effort you put in, I dont doubt that you work hard at it.

josie11:43am
Feb 19

As someone who works in broadcast media, I'd be interested in discussing the accessibility of media (new or traditional) or lack thereof to people with disabilities. And the beauty of MnSpeak is that nothing's stopping you from creating a thread to discuss that topic specifically.

So, you know, go to it, dude.

mnblrmkr  url11:47am
Feb 19

One thing I find interesting, is the number of people ridiculing the new hyper-local focus of organizations like the StarTribune and others. Can you get much more hyper-local than citizen journalism? For example, Im sure that there were hundreds of people blogging about the 35W bridge collapse. How many were much more than personal anecdote? How many even had the capacity or access to get beyond that, and start to bring us a bigger picture?

Max Sparber  url11:49am
Feb 19

Shoving a camera in the face of some unsophisticated people in a small town who have an old-style religious faith and a southern drawl is just too damned easy.

Getting back to an earlier quote. Rat, you do realize how demeaning this is. These are adult voters who were only to happy to discuss their opinions. Saying that it was somehow unfair because they're just ignorant, small-town hicks is the part that's too easy. And these exact opinions can be found all over the place, because of a sophisticated Internet whisper campaign. We're not dealing with bumbling rubes. We're dealing with people who have deliberately misinformed themselves, by latching onto lies spread on the internet, but haven't bothered to actually look into these lies. The fact that this is as common as it is disturbs me. You'll find these exact opinions among voters in Minneapolis, which is where I first heard them.

noodleman  url11:52am
Feb 19

Evangelicals weren't kidnapped by the right. The right offered them refuge from the haters.

Evangelicals have never been considered "liberal" by any means or imagination. Just look at the schism within the Lutheran Church between the two main synods ... both of which have been historically considered "conservative" but one much more so than the other. The Baptists, Assembly of God, etc., from which are drawn the greatest numbers of Evangelicals, have never had a reputation for progress politics or liberal social views.

Yes, some Evangelicals can be progressive (but finding one who will publicly acknowledge being one is next to impossible) -- but the great majority have always had conservative attitudes.

I also think it's disingenuous to claim Evangelicals had to seek "refuge from the haters." That's as blatantly false as the imagined "war of Christmas." The growing Episcopal Church schism, with a more-conservative branch departing the traditionally social-liberal core over the ordination of gay clergy, has nothing at to do with Christian hatred and everything to do with a more conservative flock wanting to depart of their own accord.

What you imagine to be "hatred" is actually scorn, maz. The kind of scorn that develops when more-aware people, religious or otherwise, encounter the very same cluelessness that's on display in the video.

The Rat (not verified)11:55am
Feb 19

The Rat doesn't like the phrase "citizen journalist" Like people who work in the business are something other than a citizen, which is what? It also implies the "citizen journalist" is doing it for some reason than to make a living. As if making a living at it means his or her efforts carries the taint of money or ambition.

Hobby Journalist seems more accurate.

mazasapa11:57am
Feb 19

How many people involved in this even think about the issue before it's brought to their attention?

I'm building a web application that links the streaming video with the transcript of that video so that as the viewer moves the slider forward and back, the script/transcript in the window beneath it moves with it. This will be used in all of my new generation online learning products.

I credit you, boilermaker, for causing me to think of the need and value of that feature.

Max Sparber  url11:58am
Feb 19

Well, if by "accurate," you mean "demeaning," then yes.

mazasapa12:00pm
Feb 19

Hey noodleman, ever hear of Jimmy Carter?

The Rat (not verified)12:01pm
Feb 19

These are adult voters who were only to happy to discuss their opinions.

Will they be happy to see their opinions interspersed with cute little graphics like "???" and "This is False." Don't remember the others. But it opens the door to all the viewers for a good chuckle.

mazasapa12:02pm
Feb 19

Hobby Journalist seems more accurate

I prefer pretend journalist.

Max Sparber  url12:03pm
Feb 19

I'm confused about why you just described misinformation as "opinion." Are you saying there is some legitimacy to the idea that Obama wants to be sworn in on the Koran?

Max Sparber  url12:05pm
Feb 19

We need to distinguish between "evangelical" and "fundamentalist." There are plenty of democrats who are evangelical Christians, despite Maz's weird proposition that atheists in the party have driven them away. Not so many Fundamentalists.

mazasapa12:08pm
Feb 19

Like "liberals" and "progressives" I admit I don't know the difference.

The Rat (not verified)12:08pm
Feb 19

No, Max. But does the "citizen journalist" have an allegiance to the truth and excise those passages he knows to be false? Or was it more important to make a fool of these people?

grote (not verified)12:10pm
Feb 19

i thought she said that he was going to be sworn in on "the korean"...and now I have this image in my mind's eye of Obama getting a piggy-back ride from Kim Jong Il.

Max Sparber  url12:10pm
Feb 19

No. And those people made fools of themselves, Rat.

mazasapa12:12pm
Feb 19

Alleged journalists with an agenda is not a new thing, Rat.

Max Sparber  url12:13pm
Feb 19

Yes. Just look at FOX.

mazasapa12:14pm
Feb 19

or SeeBS

grote (not verified)12:15pm
Feb 19

ok. let's stop this right here, fellas. this type of "discussion" might get lost on a busy commenting day on MNSpeak, but it's sticking out like a sore thumb of negativity today.

mazasapa12:16pm
Feb 19

Oh poop on you.

noodleman  url12:16pm
Feb 19

Hey noodleman, ever hear of Jimmy Carter?

Uh, yes, I have, maz. But I don't consider Carter to be an Evangelical. Born-again, yes; Evangelical, no. I doubt he considers himself to be an Evangelical, either, since his political views to not fit squarely within the limiting scope of traditional Evangelicalism.

Carter's call for human rights, etc. had little to do at the time (late '70s) with religion and everything to do with advancing US political idealism around the world. (And if our Founding Fathers truly wanted to found a Christian nation, why did they depend so much on ancient Greek and Roman political innovations?) Carter never called the Soviet Union an "evil empire" ("evil" being a religious concept, y'know); Reagan did.

nateek12:17pm
Feb 19

The misinformation those women were spewing WAS the news of the piece. Removing those quotes from the video would have defeated the purpose of the video itself.

The way Chuck put his stamp on the video maybe was comical in nature and you might have a bone to pick with how he pulled that off, but to edit those comments so that was remained was the truth would have altered the intent. This piece didn't have an agenda, per se. The woman called him Bahama, stated he was going to swear in on the Koran, and claimed he won't say the Pledge. Since her vote counts the same as everyone else's, that's worthy of attention.

The Rat (not verified)12:17pm
Feb 19

I don't think so. Nothing personal here, grote.

Max Sparber  url12:20pm
Feb 19

Jimmy Carter was a self-described Evangelical Christian. Although he recently left the Southern Baptist Convention over complaints of increased rigidity in doctrine on the organization.

The Rat (not verified)12:20pm
Feb 19

to edit those comments so that was remained was the truth would have altered the intent. This piece didn't have an agenda, per se.

What the Sam Hill is this?

It would have altered the intent, but he didn't have an agenda?

Wow!

Max Sparber  url12:23pm
Feb 19

You can have a point without having an agenda. You're falsely conflating the two, Rat. Chuck didn't make these women express their opinions, they did so willingly. And his use of graphics might be jokier than you'd find in mainstream news, but almost all news organizations would step in and explain that the claims the women were making was false.

justpbob  url12:25pm
Feb 19

Max is right, noodleman. Carter is proud to be an called an Evangelical. We should also recall how he was mocked for his beliefs by the media and the Inside the Beltway crowd.

Perhaps maz and I are the only ones here old enough to remember the Carter years.

nateek12:30pm
Feb 19

I agree that was a crappy bit of sentence construction on my part, but I'm thankful Max was able to lend me a hand.

I was trying to say that had Chuck woken up in the morning and said, "I'm going to go find some woman to say some unbelievably misguided things and then add funny graphics" then we're talking about an agenda.

If, however, he films a woman who says some unbelievably misguided things and then he broadcasts them, it seems that the intent is to illustrate the wide range of political nonsense that exists out there. To me, that's the distinction between intent and agenda.

Perhaps I've clarified, perhaps I haven't.

mazasapa12:35pm
Feb 19

had Chuck woken up in the morning and said, "I'm going to go find some woman to say some unbelievably misguided things and then add funny graphics" then we're talking about an agenda.

Well, he did drive all the way to tennessee for a reason.

Max Sparber  url12:38pm
Feb 19

Yes. To interview people.

cjc  url12:48pm
Feb 19

Hey noodleman, I know many are piling on, but to say Baptists have "have never had a reputation for progress politics or liberal social views" might be accurate, but I guess that depends where you are looking for that reputation. Dr. Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. was a Baptist. Kind of progressive, I guess...

Of course, I know a lot more progressive Baptists and Baptist organizations, but no time for linking. I have to drive a bus.

The thing is, all the old mainline Protestant denominations have liberal and conservative factions.

Whoops, gotta go.

mazasapa12:50pm
Feb 19

Perhaps maz and I are the only ones here old enough to remember the Carter years.

I actually voted for Carter ... because he was a former submarine sailor like myself.

In retrospect, it's kind of like voting for a woman for president because you're a woman or voting for a black guy for president because we've never had one before.

mnblrmkr  url12:56pm
Feb 19

As someone who works in broadcast media, I'd be interested in discussing the accessibility of media (new or traditional) or lack thereof to people with disabilities. And the beauty of MnSpeak is that nothing's stopping you from creating a thread to discuss that topic specifically.

So, you know, go to it, dude.

Josie, You think I haven't been looking for some local angle to do that? Until I find one, it's been pretty much just a side issue or comment to other posts.

And maz, thanks and your welcome. I would say that technologically, it seems to be close, it seems to be a bit more a matter of getting the content to be provided.

Raindog6612:59pm
Feb 19

Maz,

Is it kinda like voting for Bush cuz you just can't be bothered to do anything except shill for the Party Line? Or because we never had a Retarded Prez before?

Color me curious.

mazasapa01:03pm
Feb 19

No, I voted for Bush because I couldn't stomach the commies he was running against.

kc!  url01:06pm
Feb 19

Here are links for progressive Baptists.

The Association of Welcoming and Affirming Baptists
The Baptist Peace Fellowship of North American

My Baptist Church is also involved in The Fellowship of Reconciliation, Soulforce and is teaching the Living the Questions curriculum.

mazasapa01:11pm
Feb 19

Isn't "progressive baptist" an oxymoron?

noodleman  url01:13pm
Feb 19

Well, I guess I've been shown a thing or two! Perhaps I should've written "Fundamentalist" instead of "Evangelical?" Point is, no one chased religious conservatives into the arms of the GOP. They went there willingly.

And, yes, I remember Carter. I cast my first Presidential ballot in 1976. My draft number was also 302, in 1973, the last year of the draft lottery.

justpbob  url01:13pm
Feb 19

No, I voted for Bush because I couldn't stomach the commies he was running against.

Kerry the Commie? Well, never trust anyone in the Navy. I guess that leaves out McCain, too.

I hear there is a more interesting and diverse group of commies running this year, Maz.

kevinjustwantstoeat (not verified)01:14pm
Feb 19

I just read some book about Carter. He may have been more of an oaf than Bush.

mazasapa01:14pm
Feb 19

Bob, you got yer real navy and yer commie navy.

Max Sparber  url01:17pm
Feb 19

This is getting bizarre. Let me ask that we return to the subject at hand.

aliecat  url01:18pm
Feb 19

What was the subject at hand? I fergeted it...

Max Sparber  url01:20pm
Feb 19

Whatever it was, it wasn't the commie navy.

justpbob  url01:23pm
Feb 19

When Chuck and the Uptake do an expose on America's Secret Commie Navy, that's when they eat the MSM's lunch, baby!

In any case I look forward to seeing those who can make it in St. Paul, and to hearing a good presentation.

Gotta go.

mnblrmkr  url01:34pm
Feb 19

This is getting bizarre. Let me ask that we return to the subject at hand.

And I get accused of hijacking a thread for my comment.

I did my part trying to get back to the topic with my comment on hyper-localism in the msm, vs. the personalization of a lot of citizen journalism.

mazasapa01:44pm
Feb 19

And I did my part of returning the discussion to citizen journalism by mentioning Jimmy Carter who once wrote an editorial.

tara_r01:53pm
Feb 19

Maz: Like for example, I'd love to ask some young swooning girl why shy supports Obama and see what she says.

I bet it would be no less moronic.

I'm going to have to agree with Maz on this one. I have asked some Obama supporters why they support him, and most of them don't really know except to say that he stands for "HOPE!" and "CHANGE!". When you ask them what the big changes he brought about during his time in Senate are, they can't seem to answer. When you ask them what aspects of his current platform are so much more progressive and hopeful than Hillary's, they can't answer that either.

Unfortunately, there is rampant ignorance on both sides of the political fence.

mazasapa01:54pm
Feb 19

Bring back the poll tax. Only property owners should vote.

The Rat (not verified)01:58pm
Feb 19

You can't be serious

Max Sparber  url01:58pm
Feb 19

I would point out, though, Tara, that there is a difference between ignorance and misinformation. Obama supporters aren't voting for him because someone has told them that Hillary plans to institute mass castration. Ignorance is always a troubling facet of democracy, but I find out and out lying to be an even more troubling aspect. People are responsible for their own ignorance, but there's usually a concerted effort behind misinformation campaigns.

aliecat  url02:00pm
Feb 19

People are responsible for their own ignorance, but there's usually a concerted effort behind misinformation campaigns.

So, no puppies for everyone, then?

DouglasG  url02:01pm
Feb 19

Constitution be damned ! We want the poll tax!

mazasapa02:04pm
Feb 19

Hillary plans to institute mass castration

We don't know that. But my center-left 20-something son has said he wo't vote for mrs. clinton because it's outrageous that she said she's garnish his wages to pay for his health insurance, and he can't vote for obama because he's 3 years removed from the state legislature and he's too inexperienced to be running this country.

Much to my (well-hidden) shock he said he's voting for McCain because he's a straight shooter and a war hero. Oh well.

tara_r02:05pm
Feb 19

Agreed, Max. Outright lies definitely trump dopey ignorance.

The Rat (not verified)02:08pm
Feb 19

Is he equally indignant that he is forced by law to carry automobile insurance if he owns a car?

mazasapa02:09pm
Feb 19

Aren't you?

aliecat  url02:10pm
Feb 19

I'm not...but I'd carry it anyway...

The Rat (not verified)02:11pm
Feb 19

Can't say that I've considered it. But then, this isn't about me.

Mpls Simpleton (not verified)02:14pm
Feb 19

I see in the near future Maz arguing for debtor prisons.

Mpls Simpleton (not verified)02:20pm
Feb 19

In the Maz Future everyone is responsible for themselves. Few have car insurance and when they get into accidents they are bankrupted and sent to debtors prison. 50% of the population is now in jail the other half live in the Free Enterprise zone. Tort reform never occurred and now each citizen is typically sued from 100-1000 times a month. Lawyers now account for 50% of the GDP.

ADVERTISEMENT:

Did someone walk on your grass and cause irreparable damage to your lawn and psyche? Call Seiben Getz and Von Holten. We only collect if you win!

Max Sparber  url02:20pm
Feb 19

Still no word on why his left-of-center son bothers to talk politics with Mr. Maz's Wife.

mazasapa02:22pm
Feb 19

He's still a kid. What do you expect?

The Rat (not verified)02:27pm
Feb 19

So, no puppies for everyone, then?

The Rat's a Cat Person.

chuck02:38pm
Feb 19

Well, he did drive all the way to tennessee for a reason.

It's called Tennessee whiskey, son!

Actually, I embarked on this trip for The UpTake to get away from the horse race and find out what motivates voters in some of the Super Tuesday states. The South offered the most states and closest proximity.

Tennessee is where I had my only pre-planned interview, with the fellow in this video: Why the most qualified people don't run for president. He's an exectuve search consultant, very educated and wealthy - and a Mike Huckabee supporter. (Maz might like this guy, he says Newt Gingrich is a genius.)

I've seen all kinds of comments and email inventing motivations for me to interview these church ladies. What I call myself, first and foremost, is a documentary filmmaker. I like finding interesting people and telling their story. I happen to be harnessing that skill or interest into citizen journalism - an imperfect term, but one that's taken hold because it sounds empowering. And it is empowering.

I think the criticisms of my text overlays (???s, etc) are valid. The reason for them is simple - it's a playful way of fact-checking what they're saying. At the same time, it is a little snarky and I would like to release a more "pure" version that's just footage of them talking, including some snippets that didn't make it into this version discussing the separation of church and state.

Also: Graceland

kevin (not verified)02:45pm
Feb 19

Bob, I just made a Luca Brasi reference and no one got it. Take that your theory.

Max Sparber  url02:55pm
Feb 19

I thought he was dead?

No.

You said he sleep with the fishes.

What I meant was --

Ayyyyy, my pastafazole!

kc!  url03:11pm
Feb 19

I love graceland. It is so crazy, and for a mansion, really small.

Max Sparber  url03:16pm
Feb 19

People complain that Graceland, especially the Jungle Room, is done is such poor taste. I say nonsense. What did they want from The King? Danish Modernism?

kevin (not verified)03:19pm
Feb 19

When I was walking in Memphis (walking in Memphis) I was walking with my feet 10 feet off...nevermind.

aliecat  url03:21pm
Feb 19

I hated Memphis...but I was there in August many years ago and it was about 9,000 degrees with 110% humidity.

Jeff Buckley (not verified)03:22pm
Feb 19

I hate Memphis, too.

The Rat (not verified)03:23pm
Feb 19

The Rat would like to go to Memphis one day.

aliecat  url03:29pm
Feb 19

The Rat would like to go to Memphis one day.

Meh...I liked the gulf coast area better...

The Rat (not verified)03:31pm
Feb 19

You're talking about Florida?

mazasapa03:33pm
Feb 19

I stayed in a hotel in Nashville that had a geetar-shaped swimming pool. Cool.

aliecat  url03:34pm
Feb 19

You're silly, Rat.

mazasapa03:35pm
Feb 19

"You have no idea where China is, do you Bob?" heh one of my fav commercials.

aliecat  url03:36pm
Feb 19

I stayed in a hotel in Nashville that had a geetar-shaped swimming pool. Cool.

I heard that's there's actually no more southerners that live in Nashville.

Max Sparber  url03:36pm
Feb 19

I loved Memphis and would like to spend more time there. The Sun Studios and old Stax Studio (Soul USA) tours are great.

kc!  url03:42pm
Feb 19

The Civil Rights Museum is really well done. Beale Street is fun. Graceland rocks. Memphis is great.

Then head over to Nashville for more great fun like the Parthenon replica.

aliecat  url03:44pm
Feb 19

Wow, that was some shitty grammar on my part...

ericam  url04:20pm
Feb 19

Heading to Nashville for the first time other than a drive-through in a few weeks. Not really sure what to expect.

aliecat  url04:24pm
Feb 19

Heading to Nashville for the first time other than a drive-through in a few weeks. Not really sure what to expect.

My ex used to live there...be careful driving would be his advice...lots of cool music bars, too.

mazasapa04:46pm
Feb 19

be careful driving would be his advice...

Holy crap yes. Especially the mountain roads. Being tailgated by meth-soaked truckers ain't too fun on those mountain curves.

Rick Nielsen (not verified)04:59pm
Feb 19

I have a guitar shaped like a swimming pool.

kevin (not verified)05:14pm
Feb 19

That IS a guitar shaped swimming pool in my pants and I AM happy to see you.

aliecat  url05:18pm
Feb 19

Maz- my ex would tell me horror stories about the traffic deaths there, the highways can be especially hazardous because there are some areas with no shoulder. That and the truckers are assholes.

The Rat (not verified)05:44pm
Feb 19

Naah, sometimes the truckers just forget.

Red pills in the morning, blue pills at night.

They get them turned around

Puking (not verified)11:47pm
Feb 19

Punch Pizza gives you Cancer...of the Soul.

justpbob  url02:58pm
Feb 25

Robin Marty has an e-ticket for tonight's sold out MPR/UBS Forum, "New Media, New Ethics?" she can't use.

If anyone wants it, they can email Robin directly.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <i> <b> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <br> <p>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
By entering in the words in the captcha image, you help us prevent automated spam submissions and keep the site tidy.

Today's Talk

Favorite Songs About Minnesota

Mine would have to be Augie Garcia's lost classic "Be My Guest" about the River Road Club in Mendota, although I have also always been partial to The Replacement's "Skyway." What are your favorites?…

Max Sparber
0 comments »

Local Blog Roundup 01.05.08

Afterglide locates a very odd Craigslist offer.Breaking Down says Minnesota is not a state for drivers.The Deets enjoys some fine local fried food.Overheard examines the value of Timberwolves tickets.…

Max Sparber
0 comments »

Carl Pohlad Dies at Age 93

According to Star Tribune columnist Pat Reusse, on Joe Soucheray's KSTP show (reported here), Minnesota Twins owner Carl Pohlad is dead at age 93. If anyone hears any more about this, please comment.  [Update: Star Tribune confirms.]…

Max Sparber
22 comments »

Joe Dowling Makes a Lot of Money

The Strib does a story on salaries for the local arts community, and reveals that Guthrie Artistic Director Joe Dowling pulled in $682,229 in salary and benefits last year: Even discounting a one-time bonus of $100,000, his compensation surpassed tha…

Max Sparber
17 comments »

Perhaps the Greatest Andrew Zimmern Site Ever

Here is what is currently flying through the blogosphere: Andrew Zimmern Ate My Balls. Via: Almost every blog in the Twin Cities.…

Max Sparber
34 comments »

Food Invented in Minnesota

Of course, we know that Minnesota is the home of the Jucy Lucy. Also the bundt cake, or, at least, the bundt pan. Pronto Pup claims to have invented the corn dog. We're reportedly the birthplace of the cosmopolitan. Cheerios comes Golden Valley, alon…

Max Sparber
14 comments »

Read more of today's talk…